How to Choose Between Multiple Qualified Rental Applicants
Summary
When several applicants meet your written criteria, choose with a tie-breaker you decided and stated before reviewing them, such as the order complete applications arrived, rather than income, personal impressions or household type. Compare verified facts, not scores for qualities like reliability or fit. Record the reason, tell everyone else promptly and send any adverse action notice the law requires.
When several applicants meet your written criteria, a fair, defensible way to choose is a tie-breaker you set before you saw the applications and apply the same way to everyone. One straightforward option is the order in which complete applications arrived. Some cities require it.
What you should avoid is choosing on impressions, the "best" household or the highest income above your requirement. Those choices are hard to explain, easy to apply inconsistently and can stray into fair housing problems.
First, confirm each applicant actually qualifies
Before treating applicants as tied, check that each one meets every written criterion with verified information, not just answers on a form:
- Income meets your stated requirement, using the same period and calculation for everyone.
- Rental history has been checked with previous landlords where your criteria cover it. See how to verify application information.
- Any screening reports you order are reviewed against the same standards.
- Household size fits your lawful occupancy standard, and the move-in date fits what you advertised. Apply pet policies subject to applicable assistance-animal accommodation requirements.
Clarify a discrepancy before deciding what it means. An income figure reported as monthly may actually be annual; an unreachable landlord reference leaves verification unresolved rather than proving the applicant fails your criteria. Request the relevant clarification or suitable alternative evidence and allow the response time and accommodations that apply before making a decision.
Collecting rental applications?
RentForms gives you one link to send to applicants. They fill it in online and the answers arrive in your inbox.
Free. No sign-up required.
Choose a tie-breaker before you review
Write your tie-breaker into your screening criteria and, ideally, state it in your listing. Lawful options that relate to the rental itself include:
- Order of complete applications. The first applicant who meets all criteria and has submitted a complete application gets the first offer. Record the date and time each application became complete.
- Move-in date. Preference for the applicant who can start the lease closest to the date you advertised.
- Lease term. Preference for the applicant who accepts the lease length you advertised.
Pick one, or put them in a fixed order, and apply it to every applicant. Changing the tie-breaker after seeing who applied makes it look like a preference for a particular person.
Check for first-in-time rules
Local selection rules override optional tie-breakers such as a preferred move-in date or lease term. For covered advertised rentals in Portland, Oregon, follow the required receipt order, early-application adjustments and accessible-unit priorities. See Portland's application-opening and ordering process.
Seattle requires landlords to give notice of their screening criteria and offer the tenancy to the first qualified applicant with a completed application, with limited exceptions. Check your city and state for similar rules before choosing another method. See the Seattle Office for Civil Rights.
What not to use as a tie-breaker
Do not prefer or avoid applicants because of:
- Whether they have children, are pregnant or might have children. Familial status is protected under the federal Fair Housing Act.
- Marital status, or whether a couple is married. Several states, including California, protect marital status.
- Disability, including use of an assistance animal, or a need for an accommodation.
- Race, color, national origin, religion or sex, including indirect signals such as names, accents or appearance.
- Source of income, including a housing voucher, where your state or city protects it.
- Life stage, age or type of job, such as students, retirees or shift workers, unless a specific lawful rule applies.
Commute distance, "stability" and whether someone seems like a good fit for the area are also poor tie-breakers. They are subjective and tend to stand in for household type or background.
Offers above the asking rent
Some applicants offer more rent or several months in advance. Decide in advance whether you will accept offers above the advertised rent, because taking them changes who can compete for the home and may be restricted where you rent. See rental bidding and highest offers before inviting or accepting them.
Compare facts, not scores
Scoring applicants out of ten for qualities such as reliability, communication or fit gives a precise-looking number to a personal impression. Two landlords would score the same applicant differently, and so might you on a different day.
A simpler comparison lists each criterion and what was verified for each applicant: income and how it was checked, landlord references reached, report results and the date each application was complete. That shows who qualifies and, with your tie-breaker, who gets the first offer.
Keep backup applicants informed while an offer is pending
Qualifying for the home is different from receiving an offer. Make one offer at a time, following your lawful selection order. Tell other applicants that an offer is outstanding before asking them to travel, supply more documents or pay for screening. Simply saying the home is still available leaves out the information they need to decide whether to keep pursuing it. Where your process permits, defer requests for paid screening from backup applicants while the first offer is pending, instead of having everyone incur that expense at once.
Ask whether they want an update if that offer falls through, and give a realistic next-update date. Do not ask them to stop looking elsewhere or promise that the home is reserved for them. Keep the first applicant's identity and financial details private. For delays that need more explanation, see how to manage a pending application.
Do not send competing applicants payment instructions that each appear to secure the same home. Before making another offer or sending payment instructions, confirm that the earlier offer or agreement has ended under its terms and applicable law. A missed reply or an applicant changing their mind does not automatically cancel an existing commitment. Follow the applicable offer-response requirements, including any accommodation, rather than imposing a blanket next-day cutoff. Then check whether the next applicant is still interested before restarting their review.
Record the decision and tell everyone
- Write down who was offered the home, the tie-breaker you applied and the facts behind it.
- Record the offer's outcome and any remaining commitments before moving to the next applicant in order.
- Tell the others promptly. For an ordinary closeout that does not require a specific decision notice, the applicant decline message tool helps you write a short, neutral message. Check the notice requirements below first.
If information in a credit, eviction or background report played any part in turning someone down, the FTC says you must give them an adverse action notice, even if the report was a minor factor. The notice includes the screening company's details and the applicant's right to a free copy of the report and to dispute it. Some states and cities add their own steps. New Jersey, for example, requires written reasons when withdrawing a conditional offer over criminal history, an opportunity to challenge the decision, and reconsideration of evidence the applicant provides. See criminal background checks in New Jersey.
If you often get several qualified applicants
A steady supply of qualified applicants can mean your rent is below the market. A vacancy cost calculator helps you weigh a higher rent against the risk of longer vacancies when you next relist.
Sources: U.S. Department of Justice, The Fair Housing Act; FTC, Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know; Seattle Office for Civil Rights, First-in-Time; California Civil Rights Department, Housing.
Ready to collect applications?
Create your own rental application form in minutes and share it with one link.
Free. No sign-up required.
