All articles

When Can Landlords Run a Criminal Background Check in Chicago and Suburban Cook County?

Published 3 min readArticle regions: Illinois, US

Summary

For a Cook County apartment, finish reviewing the applicant’s noncriminal qualifications first. If you plan to run a criminal check, tell the applicant they passed that first step and that you’ll order the check. A screening package that starts both checks when someone applies is too early.

Set up the application before inviting anyone to apply

Cook County’s Just Housing Amendment does not require a criminal check. If you use one for a Chicago or suburban Cook County rental, take the criminal-history checkbox off the initial application. Use the form to collect what you need for your other selection criteria, such as income documentation and rental references. You can share a RentForms form for this first step and receive the answers by email.

If you rent out a room in the private home where you or a family member lives, check the private-room exception in section 42-38(c)(4). The county ordinance also addresses temporary absences from that home and cases where state or federal law requires a denial.

Before taking an application fee, give the applicant your selection criteria, including how you evaluate any convictions you may consider later. Explain how they can correct inaccuracies and submit evidence of rehabilitation or other circumstances. Include a copy of Part 700 of the Commission’s rules or a link to the Commission’s website, along with its mailing address, email and phone number. Cook County provides the notices and an assessment worksheet in its landlord FAQ.

Collecting rental applications?

RentForms gives you one link to send to applicants. They fill it in online and the answers arrive in your inbox.

Try a sample form

Free. No sign-up required.

Find out what starts the criminal search

Before you send a screening invitation, ask the provider two questions. When the applicant submits or pays, which searches actually start? After you have checked the references and other qualifications, what action lets you order the criminal search separately? A dashboard that hides a result until you click it tells you nothing about when the search ran.

For example, suppose you have the applicant’s credit report but are still waiting on a rental reference required by your criteria. Finish that review first. If the applicant qualifies, send them the prequalification notice explaining that a criminal check will follow. Then place the separate order. If the package starts both searches together, use a first-stage option that lets you finish the ordinary checks independently, or proceed without an optional criminal check. If the provider returns no criminal result, check the ordering setup before asking the applicant to do anything else.

Sections 730.110 through 730.130 of the county’s screening rules set out the sequence and a narrow exception for current sex offender registration requirements. The county also distinguishes a current child sex offender residency restriction. Neither exception authorizes a general criminal-history search at intake.

Give the applicant the report and time to respond

Deliver a copy of the report promptly when you receive it, even if the applicant has never asked for one. The landlord FAQ describes five business days for delivery, while section 740.100 says five days. Delivering it within five calendar days satisfies both timelines. Record when the applicant receives it. They then have five business days to challenge an error or explain why a conviction is irrelevant. Before a conviction-based denial, also give them a copy of your selection criteria.

Exclude arrests without convictions, juvenile records and sealed or expunged records. An ordinary conviction more than three years before the application date cannot count against the applicant. Before denying based on an eligible conviction, assess the individual circumstances even if the applicant sends no response. Consider what happened, how long ago, subsequent rental history, evidence of rehabilitation and any relevant reasonable accommodation. Identify the actual risk to other people’s safety or property.

If the applicant submits dispute information, decide within three business days of receiving it. A conviction-based denial must explain in writing why the risk makes denial necessary and tell the applicant they may file a complaint with the Cook County Commission on Human Rights. See Part 700, subparts 740 through 760 for the dispute, assessment and decision rules. If a screening company’s report contributed to an unfavorable decision, also follow the federal notice requirements described in our guide to reviewing a criminal record.

Ready to collect applications?

Create your own rental application form in minutes and share it with one link.

Create a free form

Free. No sign-up required.