All articles

Can Washington, DC Landlords Run Tenant Criminal Background Checks?

Published 7 min readArticle regions: Washington, DC, US

Summary

Washington, DC's fair criminal screening law does not require every landlord to run a criminal check. For covered rentals, landlords who choose one must make a conditional offer first; OHR directs them to wait until the applicant receives written notice before asking about criminal history or running the check, even with a signed authorization. DC also limits the records landlords may consider and requires an individual assessment before a criminal-history withdrawal.

For a landlord filling a DC vacancy, the practical question is how to separate initial application review from any later criminal screening. Set that sequence before sending an application or ordering a combined screening package. This guide covers the District of Columbia, not neighboring Maryland or Virginia, and was checked against DC law and Office of Human Rights guidance on November 15, 2026.

Check whether your rental is covered

The Fair Criminal Record Screening for Housing Act generally covers DC rentals. Its exclusions include a housing provider who owns and occupies a housing accommodation containing three or fewer rental units. Owning one rental while living elsewhere does not establish that exemption.

There are also exclusions where federal law or regulations, or District law, require criminal-history consideration or otherwise allow denial for certain convictions. Identify the actual authority for the property or housing program before relying on an exception. The statutory exclusions are at https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/42-3541.03. An exception from this Act does not remove other applicable fair housing or consumer-report duties.

Explain screening before collecting application information

DC's general tenant-screening law requires disclosures before requesting any screening information or fees, including for a free application. Provide them in writing or through an accessible posting. Follow the full list in section 42-3505.10(a), including charges and refundability, information accessed, denial criteria, reporting-agency details and report rights, rental availability, your decision timeframe and dispute rights: https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/42-3505.10. Make these disclosures before asking a prospect to complete your form, rather than waiting for a paid check.

The criminal-screening Act also requires that, before accepting an application fee, you give the applicant your eligibility criteria in writing, including the financial, employment, rental-history and criminal criteria you use. Also explain that the applicant may provide evidence of criminal-record inaccuracies, rehabilitation or other mitigating factors. OHR provides model eligibility language and notices at https://ohr.dc.gov/page/returningcitizens/housing. The models are language to adapt to your own letterhead, not completed notices for your property.

DC permits collecting signed authorization paperwork before the conditional offer. That is different from using it: do not ask the applicant to disclose pending accusations or convictions, or start that inquiry, before making the offer. A consent checkbox does not move the criminal check to the initial application stage. Charging no application fee does not remove this timing restriction.

Keep initial questions focused on the ordinary information needed to review the application. RentForms can collect those answers and deliver applications to your inbox without requiring landlord or renter registration. The conditional offer, legal notices and any permitted criminal review need a separate process.

Collecting rental applications?

RentForms gives you one link to send to applicants. They fill it in online and the answers arrive in your inbox.

Try a sample form

Free. No sign-up required.

Make an actual conditional offer before ordering the check

A conditional offer is an offer to rent a unit, subject to a later criminal inquiry or other eligibility criteria. OHR's guidance says to wait until the applicant receives written notice before making the criminal inquiry. Its model identifies the unit and the remaining conditions. A shortlist label or an invitation to continue applying does not communicate the same offer. Keep a record of delivery and receipt.

Use the model to state the actual conditions and explain how the applicant can provide corrections or mitigating information. Its blank for the number of days to submit that information describes the provider's policy; it is not a fixed DC response period. Set a reasonable process and obtain local advice if you are unsure how a proposed deadline affects the applicant's rights.

As a hypothetical workflow, you provide the required disclosures before collecting information, receive an application and signed screening authorization on Monday, review the ordinary application information, and deliver a written conditional offer on Wednesday. You arrange any permitted criminal inquiry only after confirming the applicant received it. Do not select a package on Monday that starts criminal screening immediately merely because the applicant has consented. Confirm the ordering sequence with your screening service before using it.

DC's definition allows an offer to have other eligibility conditions, and OHR's model includes them. Do not assume another city's requirement to finish every non-criminal check first is automatically the DC rule. Whatever remains outstanding should be clear in the actual offer.

Check the record type, listed offense and conviction date

A covered provider may not inquire about or consider a previous arrest that did not result in a conviction. After the offer, check pending criminal accusations and convictions separately. Both must concern offenses enumerated in section 42-3541.02(d). It is not permission to use every felony, and the list is not limited to violent crimes.

A pending criminal accusation means an existing formal charge, not simply a prior arrest. OHR's factsheet describes charges still pending when the check occurs; its eligibility and offer models also apply the seven-year limit to pending accusations. If a charge is old or its date or status is unclear, resolve that question with OHR or qualified local counsel before using it. Do not assume every unresolved case is eligible.

OHR's factsheet explains that the conviction period runs from the guilty verdict or plea, including a plea of no contest, rather than release from incarceration. For example, a conviction nine years ago does not become a conviction within the last seven years because the person left prison two years ago. Do not import New York City's release-date calculation into a DC review.

Do not ask about or require disclosure of pending accusations or convictions of a person under 18 who will live in the unit. For any record you may lawfully review, confirm the match and disposition before relying on it. Our criminal-record review guide explains those accuracy checks; DC's local limits still govern what may be used here.

The offense list, inquiry restrictions and assessment requirements appear in the current code at https://code.dccouncil.gov/us/dc/council/code/sections/42-3541.02. Resolve uncertain dates or out-of-state offense classifications before treating a report entry as eligible for consideration.

Assess the individual facts before withdrawing an offer

A reviewable record is not an automatic rejection. A criminal-history withdrawal must, on balance, serve a substantial, legitimate and nondiscriminatory interest, reasonably assessed against all six statutory factors:

  • The nature and severity of the offense.
  • The applicant's age when it occurred.
  • How much time has passed since it occurred.
  • Information supplied by or for the applicant about rehabilitation and subsequent good conduct.
  • The potential effect on other tenants' safety or property if the offense happened again.
  • Whether it occurred on, or was connected to, property the applicant rented.

Record how those factors affect the actual concern. Consider relevant information the applicant supplies, rather than treating a screening service's recommendation as the decision. Use the complete statutory list when documenting the assessment, even if a notice model summarizes it differently.

Send specific reasons and calendar the records-request deadlines

If you withdraw the conditional offer, give written notice stating the specific reasons and advising the applicant of the right to file an administrative complaint with OHR. Explain the right to request a free copy of the application records, as OHR's withdrawal model does. Preserve the information used in the review so you can respond. OHR's housing withdrawal model is available at https://ohr.dc.gov/sites/default/files/dc/sites/ohr/Notice%20of%20Withdrawal_FCRSHA_101517.pdf.

  • OHR's factsheet gives the applicant 20 calendar days after receiving the withdrawal notice to request records.
  • You must supply it free within 10 calendar days after receiving a timely request.
  • The duty covers all information relied on in considering the application, including criminal records.

Separately, section 42-3505.10(f) requires written adverse-action notice by the decision date disclosed to the applicant. It must include the specific grounds, a free copy or summary of third-party information that formed a basis for the decision, and notice of the right to dispute accuracy and permitted use. Do not wait for a records request to provide that information. Under subsection (g), respond in writing within 10 days after receiving evidence of an inaccurate or misattributed item, or use of criteria prohibited by subsection (d). That response duty is separate from the 10-day deadline for supplying requested records.

Assign someone to receive requests and record delivery and receipt of notices, requests and documents. The 20-day records-request window is not an automatic appeal decision or promise to reserve the unit. Explain the unit's status and any separate review process accurately; our application denial review guide covers handling corrections and communicating the outcome.

When a consumer report contributed to an unfavorable decision, federal adverse-action notice duties apply alongside DC's written withdrawal notice. Include the reporting agency's contact details, explain that it did not make the decision, and state the applicant's rights to dispute the report and request a free copy within 60 days. Follow the complete FTC requirements, including additional disclosures if a credit score was used: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/using-consumer-reports-what-landlords-need-know. The federal report-copy right and DC's request to the housing provider are separate obligations.

Ready to collect applications?

Create your own rental application form in minutes and share it with one link.

Create a free form

Free. No sign-up required.