All articles

Can New Jersey Landlords Run Criminal Background Checks on Tenants?

Published 7 min readArticle regions: New Jersey, US

Summary

New Jersey generally makes covered landlords wait until a conditional offer before reviewing an applicant's criminal history, and some records cannot be considered at all. A permitted conviction does not automatically justify rejection: withdrawing the offer requires an individual assessment, specific written reasons and an opportunity for the applicant to respond. The disclosure about criminal screening belongs earlier, before collecting an application fee.

New Jersey landlords can run some tenant criminal background checks, but the Fair Chance in Housing Act changes when they can ask, which records they can consider and how they must handle a denial. A standard application question about any past conviction, followed by an automatic rejection, does not fit that process.

This guide covers New Jersey's statewide rules, checked against Division on Civil Rights guidance and the published regulations on November 13, 2026. Use the state's current forms and guidance when setting up an application:

https://www.njoag.gov/fair-chance-in-housing/

First check whether the property is covered

The Act excludes a dwelling in an owner-occupied property with no more than four dwelling units. That is a property and occupancy exception, not a general exemption for anyone who owns only a few rentals. A landlord who lives elsewhere should not assume that a rented duplex is excluded merely because it is small.

Confirm the property's actual circumstances before using an exception. An exemption from this Act does not remove other fair housing or consumer-report obligations. Housing subject to program-specific eligibility requirements also needs a review of those requirements before adopting a general private-market policy.

Keep this coverage decision separate from the New Jersey application-fee cap. That law has different exceptions. Being exempt from one rule does not establish an exemption from the other.

Collecting rental applications?

RentForms gives you one link to send to applicants. They fill it in online and the answers arrive in your inbox.

Try a sample form

Free. No sign-up required.

Disclose screening before the fee, but wait to review the record

Before accepting any application fee, a covered housing provider must disclose in writing whether its eligibility criteria include criminal-history review. The disclosure must also explain that the applicant may provide evidence of inaccuracies, rehabilitation or other mitigating circumstances. DCR supplies a model disclosure; its completed and signed version satisfies the regulation's disclosure requirement. If you charge no application fee but intend to consider criminal history, provide the disclosure before considering it.

Giving that disclosure is not permission to start a general criminal-history inquiry. Before a conditional offer, the Act allows only narrow initial-application inquiries about a conviction for manufacturing or producing methamphetamine on federally assisted housing premises and a lifetime registration requirement under a state sex-offender registration program. A question about any drug conviction or any registry history is broader than those exceptions.

Remove broad criminal-history questions from the initial application and criminal-history questions from the interview. Remove blanket “no criminal record” restrictions from listings too. Check the screening service's ordering process: a package that automatically includes criminal results when you request a credit report can create a timing problem. Arrange the stages before inviting applicants to pay.

A conditional offer is an offer to rent that depends on a later criminal inquiry or other lawful eligibility criteria. Make an actual offer for the rental unit, rather than simply inviting the applicant to the next screening stage. For a clear record, put the offer, its date and its lawful conditions in writing before proceeding with the criminal review.

Separate prohibited records from records you may review

Some information stays off limits even after an offer: arrests or charges without a conviction, expunged convictions, convictions erased by executive pardon, vacated or otherwise legally nullified convictions, juvenile delinquency adjudications and sealed records. Their appearance in a report does not make them usable.

After the conditional offer, the ordinary review windows depend on the offense's degree:

  • First-degree indictable offenses: six years.
  • Second- or third-degree indictable offenses: four years.
  • Fourth-degree indictable offenses: one year.

The relevant event is the conviction or, if it resulted in a prison sentence, the conclusion of that sentence. The window runs backward from the conditional offer, not from the offense date or the day you happen to order the report. For example, an eight-year-old second-degree conviction with a prison sentence that concluded two years before the offer can fall within the four-year window. That makes it eligible for assessment, not an automatic reason to refuse housing.

A separate category permits consideration without those ordinary time limits: convictions for murder, aggravated sexual assault, kidnapping, arson, human trafficking, sexual assault, the specified offense of endangering the welfare of a child under N.J.S.A. 2C:24-4(b)(3), and crimes resulting in lifetime state sex-offender registration. Both these named categories and the degree-based time windows include qualifying federal and out-of-state equivalents. Do not treat a vendor's generic “felony” label as proof of the correct New Jersey category.

The adopted regulations list the precise offenses and statutory references in N.J.A.C. 13:5-1.8. Resolve an uncertain classification before using it against an applicant:

https://www.nj.gov/oag/newsreleases21/Published%20FCHA%20Regulations_R.2021%20d.150%20%2854%20N.J.R.%2076%28a%29%29.pdf

A permitted conviction still requires an individual assessment

Withdrawing an offer based on criminal history must be necessary to achieve a substantial, legitimate and nondiscriminatory interest, established by a preponderance of the evidence. A blanket policy against everyone with a qualifying conviction skips the required assessment. Review all six factors:

  • The nature and severity of the offense.
  • The applicant's age when it occurred.
  • The time since the offense.
  • Information about rehabilitation and good conduct supplied by or for the applicant.
  • The effect on other tenants' safety or property if the offense happened again.
  • Whether the offense occurred on or was connected to property the applicant rented.

Document how the facts affect this rental decision. Identify the actual concern and consider evidence that changes it. An applicant does not need to explain or defend a record that the law prohibits you from considering in the first place. Our broader guide to reviewing an applicant's criminal record explains report accuracy and context; New Jersey's specific limits control the review described here.

If you withdraw the offer, give reasons and handle the response

A criminal-history withdrawal needs written notification with specific reasons and an opportunity to appeal using evidence of inaccuracies, rehabilitation or other mitigating factors. “Another applicant was a better fit” does not explain a decision actually based on criminal history. DCR's model withdrawal notice helps you supply the required information, but you still need to fill in the actual reasons.

Keep these separate response obligations in your process:

  • The applicant may request the information relied on, including criminal records, within 30 days after the withdrawal notice. Supply it free within 10 days after receiving the request.
  • Review evidence of inaccuracies, rehabilitation or mitigating factors and reconsider the decision. The regulation says the determination after reconsideration should be provided within 30 days; DCR's guidance directs providers to respond within 30 days based on the new information received.
  • If the applicant shows that a record is inaccurate, confirm its accuracy before continuing to rely on it.

DCR's model disclosure describes a right to dispute relevance and accuracy and offer mitigating evidence within 10 days of receiving that statement. It also expressly allows evidence of inaccuracies, rehabilitation or mitigating factors after those 10 days. Do not turn that wording into a blanket cutoff for reviewing an applicant's evidence.

When a consumer report contributed to the decision, also follow the federal adverse-action requirements. These include the reporting company's contact details, an explanation that it did not make the rental decision, and the applicant's rights to dispute inaccuracies and obtain a free report within 60 days. State withdrawal procedures do not replace those obligations. The FTC explains them here:

https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/using-consumer-reports-what-landlords-need-know

Make sure your screening service follows the same sequence

New Jersey requires reasonable steps to ensure that a screening vendor follows the Act. If a report reveals prohibited records, the housing provider must be able to show that it did not rely on them. An automated recommendation is therefore something to examine, not a substitute for your own permitted-record review and assessment.

Before using a service, confirm when criminal results become available, how New Jersey categories and dates are handled, and how you can obtain the information behind a decision. Keep a record of the fee disclosure, offer, permissible information considered, assessment, notices and responses. That lets you explain the real decision and correct an error without asking the applicant to start the entire application again.

Ready to collect applications?

Create your own rental application form in minutes and share it with one link.

Create a free form

Free. No sign-up required.