All articles

NYC Broker Fees: When Your Listing Agent Charges the Tenant

Published 6 min readArticle regions: New York State, US

Summary

In New York City, a landlord can be liable when their agent or listing agent charges a tenant a prohibited broker fee. If an applicant reports a charge you did not approve, stop the disputed collection and compare the listing, agency agreement and payment records. Correcting the applicant's costs also means fixing the agent's instructions and disclosures for everyone still applying.

An NYC broker fee problem can reach a landlord as a simple question: why does the agent's payment request differ from the price the owner approved? The applicant may have a listing, a message and a payment link that tell three different stories. Sending them back to the agent without checking those records leaves the underlying problem unresolved.

This guide concerns New York City residential rentals under the Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses Act, known as the FARE Act, effective June 11, 2025. It addresses current listing and application practices. An older contractual obligation needs its own review; rules elsewhere in New York are not identical to this city law.

Start with who the broker represents

NYC's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection explains that a landlord's agent, including an agent who publishes a listing with the landlord's permission, cannot charge the prospective tenant a broker fee. The landlord can be liable for that charge. Publishing a listing creates a rebuttable presumption of the landlord's authorization. See the agency's FARE Act FAQ: https://www.nyc.gov/site/dca/about/FAQ-Broker-Fees.page.

A tenant may independently choose and pay their own broker. However, access to a particular apartment cannot depend on hiring a broker, including a dual agent. A last-minute representation form does not make a required listing-agent payment voluntary.

Ask for the actual agency agreement and the listing history. Who authorized publication? Who provided the photos, keys and asking rent? Did the renter hire someone to search on their behalf, or simply respond to this apartment's advertisement? Review what happened before relying on a label such as tenant representative. Where authorization is disputed, preserve the evidence and get the arrangement reviewed.

Collecting rental applications?

RentForms gives you one link to send to applicants. They fill it in online and the answers arrive in your inbox.

Try a sample form

Free. No sign-up required.

Pause the fee request and reconstruct the offer

When a complaint arrives, designate one person to coordinate the review. Tell the agent to pause the disputed collection and prevent automated reminders from continuing while you establish the facts. Give the applicant a clear contact and a realistic time for the next update. Do not ask them to pay first so that the application can keep moving.

Save the original advertisement before correcting it. Collect the written rent authorization, each fee request, any proposed lease, and the agency's explanation of who receives the money. Request the applicant's relevant messages or receipt without demanding unrelated account transactions. Keep originals with their dates rather than replacing them with a cleaned-up version.

Compare the amounts side by side: monthly rent, one-time charges, recipient and stated purpose. For example, an owner may approve one rent while an agent offers applicants a choice between a lower rent plus a fee and a higher rent without it. That discrepancy needs review before either offer proceeds. A menu of prices does not itself establish that the fee is lawful or that the agent had authority to negotiate rent.

Keep the fee complaint separate from the rental decision. Preserve the applicant's place in your stated process while you clarify the offer, and apply the same lawful screening criteria used for other applicants. Asking about an unexplained charge is useful information about your process.

Make the listing and written disclosure agree

Under the FARE Act, rental advertisements must clearly disclose all required tenant fees and cannot include an unlawful broker fee. Before lease signing, the tenant must sign an itemized written disclosure describing fees payable to the landlord or anyone at the landlord's direction. Give the tenant a copy and retain the signed disclosure for three years. Disclosure does not make a prohibited charge lawful.

Once the review establishes the correct offer, update every channel your agent controls, including syndicated listings, showing instructions and payment pages. A corrected advertisement will not fix an older message already sitting in an applicant's inbox. Contact affected applicants directly with the corrected information and explain which earlier instruction they should disregard.

Review screening charges separately. Removing a broker fee should not lead to the same amount reappearing as an application or processing charge. Our New York rental application fee guide explains the ordinary screening-cost limit and recent-report waiver. Those requirements address a different expense and need their own supporting records.

If money was collected, follow it through to resolution

Establish whether the applicant paid, the amount, the recipient and whether the transaction settled. An invoice marked canceled is not proof that a collected payment was returned. If the charge was improper, coordinate its correction with the brokerage and obtain a record of the repayment, rather than leaving the applicant to relay messages between you.

Explain who is handling the return and when the applicant should expect confirmation. If there is a genuine dispute about payment or representation, identify that specific issue and have it reviewed promptly. Do not make correction depend on the applicant withdrawing a complaint, posting a favorable review or signing away unrelated concerns.

DCWP's enforcement guidance explains that sustained FARE Act violations can bring civil penalties and restitution. The agency's implementation announcement is available at https://www.nyc.gov/site/dca/news/018-25/dcwp-the-fare-act-now-effect. Keep payment and communication records available if a complaint is filed; an informal resolution should not involve deleting the original evidence.

Give the brokerage clear limits before the next listing

Review the service agreement with the brokerage's responsible supervisor. Specify who approves rent, concessions, tenant-facing fees and changes to the listing. Identify who prepares the fee disclosure and who checks that the tenant receives it before signing. A vague instruction to follow local law leaves practical ownership of these tasks unclear.

  • Approve the initial advertisement and the complete payment instructions before they are sent.
  • Require written approval before the agent changes the rent or offers a concession.
  • Keep an owner contact available for applicants who receive conflicting information.
  • Review a sample of actual applicant communications, including payment requests.
  • Check that corrections reach other staff or agents working on the same apartment.

For the broader division of responsibility, see our leasing-only service agreement guide. The NYC fee review belongs alongside that scope of work, rather than being left to a general commission clause.

Close the issue when the records agree: the advertised offer, applicant instructions, permitted charges and any repayment. Then check the next application using that same process. The useful outcome is an offer that both the landlord and applicant can understand without having to negotiate away an unexpected fee.

Ready to collect applications?

Create your own rental application form in minutes and share it with one link.

Create a free form

Free. No sign-up required.