All articles

Can NYC Landlords Run Criminal Background Checks on Tenants?

Published 6 min readArticle regions: New York State, US

Summary

Most NYC landlords who choose criminal screening must finish the other eligibility checks and make a written conditional housing offer first. Only limited convictions may then be reviewed, and an unfavorable decision requires time for the applicant to respond and an individual assessment. The unit stays available during that process, so the screening order matters as much as the report.

Can NYC landlords still run criminal background checks on tenants? For covered rentals, yes, but the Fair Chance Housing Law changes when the check happens, what it can contain and how the result can affect an application. It took effect January 1, 2025. An ordinary application followed immediately by a combined credit and criminal report can put the steps in the wrong order.

This guide addresses New York City rentals. The city procedure is separate from New York State's screening-fee and housing-court-history restrictions. A statewide screening checklist cannot resolve every NYC decision.

Establish whether the rental is covered

The city code excludes certain buildings housing no more than two families independently when the owner or the owner's family lives in one accommodation. It separately excludes rooms rented by a resident occupant, or by an owner who lives there or whose family lives there. Neither exception applies to publicly assisted housing. Owning a small rental portfolio by itself does not establish an exemption; check the exact arrangement against section 8-107(5)(o)(8) of the code linked below.

State or federally funded housing can have specifically required or authorized criminal-history actions. Identify the particular program rule; funding does not give every provider unrestricted permission to order a broad criminal report. Cite the authority in any specially permitted advertising or application language and notify the applicant of the authority for a criminal-history denial. When the authority allows rather than requires adverse action, the Fair Chance process still applies. The Commission explains coverage at https://www.nyc.gov/site/cchr/media/fair-chance-housing-campaign.page.

Make the coverage decision once for the property, with appropriate advice if its status is unclear. Record the basis and give the same instructions to the owner, broker and screening company. Otherwise, a broker may order the usual package while the owner assumes criminal screening has been postponed.

Collecting rental applications?

RentForms gives you one link to send to applicants. They fill it in online and the answers arrive in your inbox.

Try a sample form

Free. No sign-up required.

Finish ordinary screening before making the conditional offer

Covered providers must review all lawful non-criminal eligibility materials first. That can include ability to pay and rental references. Remove criminal-history questions from this initial stage, including informal questions during a showing. The city's rules also restrict criminal-history statements in advertisements and applications. For the ordinary covered rental, advertising that a criminal background check is required is prohibited, even if you intend to wait until after an offer to run it.

Keep the application moving through clear stages: documents received, ordinary eligibility reviewed, conditional offer issued, and any permitted criminal review. These are useful internal statuses, not new legal categories. Their purpose is to make it obvious who can authorize the next step.

Before any criminal check, provide a written lease or rental agreement that conditionally commits a unit, together with notice of the intended criminal check and the Commission's written Fair Chance Housing Notice of Rights. A message saying the applicant has reached a shortlist does not do the same job. Use the current official notice, available in several languages at https://www.nyc.gov/site/cchr/law/legal-resources.page.

Coordinate the agreement and screening instruction before sending either. For example, if references remain unchecked, finish that work instead of calling the application conditionally approved to unlock a report. A conditional offer is a real commitment, not an administrative shortcut.

The code permits withdrawal for an unrelated material omission, misrepresentation or change in tenancy qualifications that was unknown when the offer was made. That is different from leaving routine financial screening unfinished or using criminal history as an undisclosed reason to withdraw.

Limit the check to reviewable convictions

NYC's definition generally permits only convictions requiring sex-offender registration at the time of the check, other felony convictions where less than five years have passed, and other misdemeanor convictions where less than three years have passed. Measure the latter periods from release from incarceration, or sentencing if the applicant was not sentenced to incarceration, to the housing application date, as described in the Commission's FAQ. Do not automatically use the conviction date. Current registry status is assessed at the time of the background check.

Important exclusions still apply, including arrests, pending cases, sealed or expunged convictions and other protected dispositions. A recent date does not make every record reviewable. The full definition and housing provisions are in sections 8-102 and 8-107(5)(o) at https://www.nyc.gov/site/cchr/law/chapter-1.page.

Ask the screening provider how it separates credit from criminal searches and excludes prohibited records. Check the actual report configuration, not just the package name. A national product's default settings do not demonstrate that your NYC workflow is correct. Our criminal-record review guide explains the separate questions of identity matching, record accuracy and permitted use.

Keep the unit available while the applicant can respond

Before an unfavorable action based on reviewable criminal history, provide written copies of the criminal-history information received or reviewed, including prohibited records received even if ignored. Give written notice of the five-business-day opportunity to respond. Applicants may identify errors, point out prohibited information or provide context and supporting evidence. The unit must remain available through the Fair Chance process and individual assessment.

Set the response deadline from receipt, accounting for weekends and holidays. Name the person who receives corrections and make sure a leasing colleague cannot release the unit while that person is reviewing them. Keep the documents, delivery record, response and decision together so the next person can understand what happened without reconstructing an email chain.

The Commission's notice explains both the response right and the obligation to assess the application even if the applicant submits nothing further: https://www.nyc.gov/assets/cchr/downloads/pdf/publications/FairChanceHousing-Notice.pdf. Silence is not a replacement for the required review.

Explain the individual decision before withdrawing an offer

A reviewable conviction does not automatically justify rejection. Before withdrawing the offer, send the applicant a written explanation connecting it to a legitimate business interest and explaining how their individual information was considered, together with copies of the supporting documents reviewed. General assumptions about people with convictions do not establish that link. Requiring a new co-signer or worse lease terms because of criminal history is not an alternative to this process.

Write the assessment before sending the outcome. If the explanation says only that the report failed or that the owner is uncomfortable, the decision still needs work. Separate an inaccurate match, a prohibited record and a permitted conviction requiring assessment; each presents a different problem.

Consumer-report decisions can also trigger federal adverse-action notices. Follow the FTC's requirements alongside the NYC process, including additional disclosures if a credit score was used: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/using-consumer-reports-what-landlords-need-know. Sending a federal notice does not make otherwise prohibited screening permissible.

Check the other New York rules separately

Splitting screening into stages does not remove the state's fee restrictions. Use our New York screening-fee guide for the actual-cost ceiling, $20 limit and recent-report waiver. A separate criminal check is not a fresh allowance to charge another full screening fee.

Also review the New York housing-court-history rules. Criminal history and landlord-tenant court involvement are different subjects with different restrictions. Before opening applications, align the listing, application questions, report order, offer and decision notices with the rules for this particular property.

Ready to collect applications?

Create your own rental application form in minutes and share it with one link.

Create a free form

Free. No sign-up required.