All articles

Oakland Tenant Screening: Can Landlords Check Criminal History?

Published 5 min readArticle regions: California, US

Summary

Oakland generally prohibits covered landlords from asking about or using criminal history when screening tenants. The practical response is to remove those questions and checks from the application process, while keeping lawful financial and rental qualification checks. Narrow exceptions have their own conditions and do not authorize a routine criminal report for every applicant.

Oakland's tenant criminal-background-check restrictions change the contents of a screening process, not just the wording of a rejection. For covered rentals, ordering the report and quietly choosing another applicant does not solve the problem. The city's Fair Chance Access to Housing Ordinance generally prohibits criminal inquiries and housing decisions based on criminal history.

This is an Oakland guide, not a California-wide ban on tenant screening. Start with the property's actual jurisdiction before copying a form or buying a nationwide screening package.

Check coverage before ordering any report

The ordinance excludes a single-family home occupied by its owner as a principal residence, and a unit in a property divided into no more than three units when the owner lives in one as a principal residence. An accessory dwelling unit's label alone does not establish the exemption; check the whole property arrangement.

Other exclusions cover a unit previously occupied by its owner as a principal residence where a written agreement with current tenants preserves the owner's right to recover it as a principal residence, and an occupying tenant's replacement or addition of a co-tenant or sublet while that tenant remains. Confirm the exact facts before treating a roommate arrangement as exempt.

The city also describes limited registry checks and checks required for certain affordable housing. Those have specific conditions. Confirm which exception applies and to whom before using it. The city's overview, FAQ and notice downloads are at https://www.oaklandca.gov/Community/Housing-Programs-Support/Fair-Chance-Housing-Ordinance.

Keep a short property-level note explaining the coverage decision. If a manager handles both an owner-occupied duplex and a separate apartment building, the same screening instructions may not fit both. Resolve that difference before applicants receive links to the wrong package.

Collecting rental applications?

RentForms gives you one link to send to applicants. They fill it in online and the answers arrive in your inbox.

Try a sample form

Free. No sign-up required.

Remove criminal screening from the whole application process

For covered rentals without an applicable exception, the restrictions reach advertisements, application questions, required criminal-history authorizations and negative decisions. Charging more rent or a higher deposit because of criminal history is also prohibited. Changing the label from rejection to conditional acceptance does not avoid the restriction.

Review the places where criminal information could enter your process:

  • Listing text and the first message sent to prospective applicants.
  • Online and paper forms, including inherited questions from an old application.
  • The actual checks included in a screening package.
  • Instructions given to a broker, assistant or reference-checking service.

Ask the provider what the selected package returns and whether criminal searches can be disabled. Do not choose a bundle just because it is the default or cheapest option. If its contents cannot be made suitable for the property, choose a process that can.

Oakland also requires its Notice to Applicants and Tenants to appear prominently in application materials, websites and other locations under the provider's control frequently visited by housing applicants. Download the city notice rather than replacing it with a homemade sentence. The landlord notice explains this requirement at https://www.oaklandca.gov/files/assets/city/v/1/housing-comm-dev/documents/fair-chance/website-landlord-notive-with-tenant-notice-attached.pdf.

Keep lawful qualification checks focused on the tenancy

Removing criminal screening does not mean abandoning an application review. The city's provider presentation distinguishes criminal records from other rental criteria, such as income verification and references. Those checks remain subject to applicable fair-housing, consumer-reporting and California rules.

Decide what evidence answers each permitted question. For ability to pay, identify the lawful evidence you accept and how you review it. For references, ask about the tenancy information you actually need. Do not turn an unexplained gap in an application into a request for criminal history or use another person to obtain information you have removed from your own form.

Keep the reason for a decision tied to the permitted criterion and the evidence actually used. A broad screening score can be difficult to interpret if its inputs are unclear. Ask what produced a recommendation before relying on it, especially when a vendor combines several kinds of information into one result.

Fees are a separate issue. Our California application-fee and refund guide explains the screening processes and refunds. A lawful charge does not establish that every check included in the purchased package is lawful for an Oakland property.

Treat the exceptions as separate procedures

Oakland's limited state lifetime sex-offender-registry exception is not permission to order a general criminal report. It is tied to the state-law purpose of protecting persons at risk. The ordinance requires written application disclosure, completion of other rental criteria, a conditional rental agreement and advance notice of the search. Request written consent; if the applicant objects, provide an opportunity to withdraw the application. Review the full requirements before choosing this option.

For affordable housing, identify a federal or state law requiring exclusion based on specific criminal history. The city FAQ expressly distinguishes required screening from optional checks, which are not permitted under this exception. Give advance notice of the specific check, request written consent and offer withdrawal if the applicant objects. Denial under this exception must rest on the state or federal requirement. A provider's usual policy is not itself a legal mandate.

Before a final unfavorable decision based on criminal history under a permitted exception, the city requires written notice and an opportunity to provide rebutting or mitigating information. Supply the reasons, copies of the records supporting the decision, city complaint instructions and a list of local legal services with contact information. Do not charge for supplying the criminal-history material. Account for the response process before treating the result as final.

For a property relying on an exception, assign someone to check both the exception and its conditions. Record the authority, scope of the search, communications and response. Avoid a general instruction such as approved for criminal screening, which leaves the next person guessing how much screening is allowed.

These conditions appear in sections 8.25.020 through 8.25.040. The City Council's adopted ordinance is attached as 13581 CMS to the legislative record at https://oakland.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=4205413&GUID=772233A8-44FA-4BA1-938F-02D30D7D2905.

Keep local restrictions and federal report notices separate

When a consumer report contributes to an unfavorable rental decision, federal adverse-action notice duties can apply even if the report was not the main reason. Additional credit-score disclosures may also be required. The FTC explains those duties at https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/using-consumer-reports-what-landlords-need-know. Federal notice compliance does not authorize a criminal check that Oakland prohibits.

If an unsuitable report arrives, pause before relying on it or sending an outcome. Preserve the relevant records and obtain advice on the affected application; silently changing the reason does not correct an improper process. Then fix the package settings and instructions that allowed the information to arrive.

Section 8.25.040 requires retaining criminal-history information obtained about an applicant for at least three years and keeping it confidential to the extent the law permits. That applies to the handling of a received report, not just your preferred final decision notes. Restrict access and document who is responsible for retention instead of deleting an unsuitable report to make the problem disappear.

For broader record-matching and decision-review issues, see our guide to criminal records in rental applications. For Oakland, begin one step earlier: establish that the proposed inquiry is permitted at all.

Ready to collect applications?

Create your own rental application form in minutes and share it with one link.

Create a free form

Free. No sign-up required.